Archive for the ‘Microchip’ Category

PCIM 2016 Highlights

Monday, May 30th, 2016

PCIM was big – again

PCIM 2016 Highlights

This year PCIM filled three of the Messe exhibition hall in the Nuremberg.  There were a large number of exhibitors.  This large turnout of exhibitors and the crowds attending shows that power electronics is going well in Europe and the world.  The recent reasonable GDP growth in Europe suggests that the financial crisis of 2008 may finally no longer be a drag on the European economies.

Devices

Always at PCIM there are new and exciting devices launched.  There is always lots of talk of how these devices will solve all the power loss and control problems.  Better devices are always worth having and they add to the toolbox for power electronics engineers.  Typically these new and improved switching devices allow higher power density by reducing losses and increasing the operating temperatures.  As an end in themselves new devices are often a bit of a distraction.  The fundamentals of the power converters job stay the same.  Thermal design to keep the heat out, EM design to keep the noise in and control the converter to be stable and useful.

Gallium Nitride GaN

The GaN story is a good one. It is easy to be cynical about why GaN has appeared in the commercial market after being used extensively in military application for some time. The key issues that were clear in talking to GaN people was that the expected improvement from silicon is not as large as expected or as was initially indicated and that driving the devices is a challenge. As GaN devices are FET type devices with ON resistance they will be limited to lower voltages possibly up to 700VDC to 800VDC.

Gallium Nitride Molecular structure PCIM 2016 Highlights

GaN is touted as the future for semiconductors. Solving the reliability issues may be the most pressing challenge to enable adoption.

Another issue with GaN devices is a perceived low reliability.  This may resolve and my guess is it will as I remember when I first started working with IGBTs in 1990 they too were considered “unreliable.”

Silicon Carbide

Silicon carbide devices are well established and there are lots of switching devices and diodes available.  These devices are being used to move the switching frequency up which is often assumed to be a good thing.  The question that industry veteran Marty Brown so eloquently asks about this is “why go faster?”  Time will tell whether faster switching gives the advantages that it should.

Silicon and stacks

Silicon devices are going from strength to strength. The effort being put into system design with gate drives and cooling is high. It is now possible to buy megawatt converters in cabinets ready for deployment into wind and solar applications. Vendors like Semikron, Danfoss and Infineon are leading the way with smaller vendors like Oztech and Agilestack either following quickly and at times leading.

It is still possible to use discrete devices. When talking with a vendor of an impressive graphite thermal interface material it was clear that they were surprised by the large numbers of TO247 packages being used in high volumes.

Capacitors

The trade off between required capacitor size and the switching frequency of three phase inverters is one of those design iteration choices that defines the physical size of the converter. If the switching is faster then there is less DC side capacitance needed but the switching losses are higher. And as we all switch faster is this optimization is starting to be limited by the inductance of the commutation loop. The available DC bus capacitors are very low inductance and the laminated DC bus bars are also extremely low inductance. There are opportunities to connect the capacitors directly onto the DC bus bars reducing the inductance to a very low value. SBE Capacitors have an excellent solution

Infineon-450V-1000uF-290

Safety Critical Controllers – Functional Safety

The use of safety critical approaches in digital power control is recent. The automotive power electronic people have ISO 26262 requirements for how the gate drives and how the hardware need to behave in a fault. Medical device compliance requirements have long required risk management and safety critical partitioning of the system. Even household appliances have safety critical requirements in their product standards like IEC/EN 60335 and IEC/EN 60730. We have had 60730 code libraries for a number of processors for a while now and have IEC 61508 as the basis for our high reliability controllers. And the work that we do with controllers in equipment covered by the Machinery Safety Directive gives us a good insight into product risk management over the complete product lifecycle.

For a long while, and until recently, there has been little support for safety critical systems in power electronics. Partitioning of the controller is the way to meet the fault detection requirements of safety critical systems was a challenge. With the advent of ISO26262 in the auto industry there is now a demand for safety critical assessment and traceability inside the power converter controller. The use of safety critical techniques has long been useful in power converter control due to the inherent ability of bridge power converters to self-destruct.

There were microprocessors at PCIM which have (or will have) safety critical function as key to their function.  These microprocessors have multiple cores that can implement either dual redundant systems or primary and secondary control to implement the safety critical control. This development is a great acknowledgement that there is need to treat power electronic systems as part of the safety critical development. Often times in the past the digital control in the power converter was not subjected to the same level of review and revision control.  And often the digital control in the power converter can be updated in the field, leading to security issues for the digital power converter controller.

While micros with the partition and the safety critical features are a good step toward this there is probably still risk of hackers compromising the security of network connected safety critical systems. Engineering to avoid a Stuxnet type vulnerability in power converter controllers will be the challenge.

ELMG Control Platform for Safety Critical Systems

The ELMG Digital Power Control Platform allows safety critical partitioning of the FPGA function. The Xilinx isolated design flow ensures that each part of the the system can be separately verified and maintained. ELMG Digital Power experience in digital control for safety critical applications such as medical, household appliances and automotive traction allows safety critical analysis and design to appropriate process and performance standards.

Contact us to discuss your safety critical system.

 

 

Digital power electronics control processor choice – critical to success

Monday, December 8th, 2014

Digital power electronics control processor

The choice of control processor for your digital power converter is the most critical.  Which one should you choose from the multitude of available options?

A good lunch is all it takes

An engineer at our recent digital control course told me that the answer at his company was all about whether the FAE had taken you out for a good lunch.

He then went on to say that they had recently changed their digital power electronics control processor late in a development because this lunch approach to selection had not worked out so well.

What is important in a processor?

In a recent survey and discussion in the exclusive members only ELMG LinkedIn Digital Control Group  the most popular features and benefits of the digital power electronics control processor suggested were these. (not in any particular order of priority).

  • Price
  • Number of bits
  • ADC Precision
  • ADC sample and hold time
  • ADC aperture time
  • ADC delay
  • Tool chain flexibility and support
  • Emulation ability
  • Debug
  • Floating point
  • Fixed point
  • Device package
  • Processing power

Interrupts? PWM capability?

There was no mention of interrupt capability and no mention of PWM precision or PWM peripheral capability.  This may be because it is no longer the issue it was fifteen years ago.

Boundary scan and what we have always done

Surprisingly no one mentioned boundary scan for testing which we at ELMG find very useful.

Also surprising that the “we have used this processor forever and so will not change” was not mentioned in the Linkedin group discussion.

Will the purchasing department choose?

Before we get into technical details of processors it is useful to step back and remember that the supply chain for the chip needs to be secure.  Typically to a purchasing person this means that

  • The supplier is not going to go out of business.
  • The supplier has committed to not discontinuing the part.
  • The supplier’s balance sheet is not a large risk.
  • The supplier does not present a geographic or political risk.  If you are going to buy processors in large volumes natural disasters and revolutions can effect availability.
  • The supplier has good pricing.

If you are find yourself in the situation where there is no engineering choice of supplier best steps are to assess the proposed digital power electronics control processor against the “what is important” list above.

Some digital power electronics control processor options

There are a large number of processors that will do a good job.

A few stand out as having proved themselves useful over the years.

  • Microchip PIC and DSPic series
  • Luminary Stellaris Cortex M3
  • Ti  C2000 Series
  • Xilinx FPGA

Microchip

Microchip make great power control processors.  The processors and the peripherals around them are a really good choice of control processors for power electronics.  Typically purchasing departments love Microchip as a supplier.

Key strengths of the PIC and DSPic parts are the great support from Microchip and the microchip community. There are a large number of development kits that are available where the code, circuit and PCB layouts are all made available.  Examples of these include a 200W microinverter design and digital power starter kit.

Luminary Micro

Luminary microprocessors are ARM Cortex M3 parts.  The parts are excellent as they leverage the ARM eco-system of tools.  Initially we were reluctant to use these as the Luminary balance sheet was not as strong as it could be.  Then Texas Instruments (Ti) bought Luminary and integrated the products into the Ti range.  It is possible that Ti are not as committed as they were to the Luminary M3 parts.  Before you consider these parts make sure to ensure that the risk, or otherwise, of the processor being discontinued is clear.

Texas Instruments – C2000 series

Ti make very good digital power electronic controller processors.  The C2000 series provide a wide range of processors for power electronics.

Key features of these parts that make them most useful are

  • Very flexible three phase PWM
  • Good ADCs with synchronized sampling for three phases
  • Good code protection
  • Good tool chain

A part numbering example is TMS320F2812. The TMS320 is the family.  The F identifies the flash part and the 2812 is the model number.  The part is referred to as the twenty eight twelve.  This particular model is 32 bit with sixteen 12 bit ADCs and sixteen PWM channels.  This twenty eight twelve processor has been the workhorse for many motor drives and power supplies.  Other variants including the 2808 (twenty eight oh eight) are equally useful.

To extend the range upward Ti provide the Delfino range typified by the TMS320F28335 (twenty eight three three five). This is a floating point part.  The lower end of the range is covered by the Piccolo which is typified by the TMS320F28027. (Twenty eight oh two seven).

Why is it called the C2000 series?

The entire family of the C2000 series use the same code tools, and, if the code is structured well  it can be ported directly from one processor to the other.

Want to keep in touch.  Follow our blog

And it is called the C2000 series because the first parts available were ROM parts which had a C in the part number (C is short for ROM) instead of the F for Flash.

Product Support

Ti product support is good though it can be a little slow at times.  Pre-release silicon, labelled TMX, is often available from your local Ti supply chain.

The part data sheets are comprehensive and the discussion forums hosted by Ti are useful and often very productive.

Ti has a number of my favorite digital power electronic controller parts including the 2812 and the 28027.

Xilinx FPGA

The Xilinx FPGAs are not strictly designed as power electronics control processors.  They are Field Programmable Gate Arrays and so can do anything imaginable.  FPGA’s suit power electronics control very well.

Customised Peripherals

Often it is the peripherals in a power electronics processor that force the choice.  Typically a requirement for ADCs with a certain sample rate and a PWM that can make a certain waveform without excessive processor load force a certain choice.

If the MCU with the exact right combination of peripherals that you want does not exist then extra hardware is required.  Typically the selection process for an off the shelf processor part is always a compromise.

As an example, a peripheral set like

  • 4 UARTs,
  • 3 CAN Bus connections
  • 3 Ethernet along with
  • A five level three phase converter switching control with dead time compensation

can be implemented in a FPGA but a processor at reasonable price with this exact feature set is unlikely.

The beauty of the FPGA in this situation is that it’s peripheral set can be made totally customisable.  The design can be exactly as you need it.

Off the Shelf IP Core blocks

There are a number of off the shelf (OTS) IP Core blocks that can be used.  HDMI, SATA, VGA, Quad SPI, I2C, USB, high-speed serial, PCIe, UART, SPI, I2C, Ethernet and industrial ethernet like Ethercat  are all available off the shelf.  There are even open source solutions for some of these blocks.  These open source solutions come with very little support.  Commercial and proven blocks with support from vendors are usually better.

When building a power electronic controller the ELMG power electronics Control IP Core Blocks such as space vector modulators, phase locked loops and resonant controllers can be used along with off the shelf Ethernet stacks, USB connections and CAN bus controllers.  This gives a powerful custom digital power electronics control processor.

Extremely Complex Control – Too complex for the average engineer?

Complex control systems for power converters can be implemented using FPGAs.  This allows maximum flexibility and it allows the controller to be put into an ASIC for cost down when sales volume increases.

This complexity is a perceived risk for many teams when approaching FPGA.   However, since the FPGA is logic and a processor  is a connection of logic gates – why not put one inside the FPGA?  Then software engineers can use their existing expertise  with the added power of the FPGA.

Soft cores

This processor in an FPGA is implemented in a soft core.   A soft core, such as Xilinx’s Microblaze, is a micro built out of FPGA fabric.

The beauty of a soft core is that it can take any shape; small in size, really fast, an MPU or an MCU, with a multiplier or not. This allows you to size the softcore to your application.

Peripherals are then attached to the soft core. As an example, a custom three level PWM, 4 UARTs and 2 SPIs and you can then write C code for the soft core.

To take advantage of the FPGAs power add an ELMG Digital Power IP core block to accelerate the C code where it needs to be fast.  This allows you to use your existing C coding capability.

As an example, perform data transfer from an ADC using C, filter it fast and efficiently in FPGA fabric and then use the soft core with C to send it to a DAC or a custom PWM.

Best digital power electronics control processor?

The best digital power electronics control processor platform depends on the application.  Processors such as those from Microchip, Luminary and Texas Instruments are very good and are typically a good choice.  The ADC, processing and PWM performance determines which processors are suitable.  Additional communications and control peripherals then decide which processor part is best.

Click here to contact us for help in choosing processors.

Successful power converter developments and products use and have used the Microchip, Luminary and Ti parts.

FPGA based controllers for digital power provide power and flexibility that is a level above these standard digital power electronics control processors.  The ability to use soft core processors and FPGA  off the shelf IP along with the Digital Power IP Core Blocks makes the controllers more flexible and more useful.

The ELMG Digital Power IP Core Blocks are planned for release in March 2015.  See the list of proposed ELMG Digital Power IP Core Blocks blocks by clicking here

Want to keep in touch.  Follow our blog